Settler colonial and indigenising: Zada Ballew, ‘”The Indian Side of the Question”: Settling the Story of Potawatomi Removal in the Twentieth-Century Midwest’, The Journal of the Gilded Age and Progressive Era, 2024 | settler colonial studies blog

Settler colonial and indigenising: Zada Ballew, ‘”The Indian Side of the Question”: Settling the Story of Potawatomi Removal in the Twentieth-Century Midwest’, The Journal of the Gilded Age and Progressive Era, 2024

21May24

Abstract: In 1893, Simon Pokagon, a leader of the “unremoved” Pokagon Band of Potawatomi, published a birchbark pamphlet titled The Red Man’s Rebuke. This story condemned settlers for dispossessing Native peoples of their lands and removing them west of the Mississippi River in service of their “civilization.” Pokagon’s Rebuke remains one of the most cited texts in Native American history. But what happened to Pokagon’s message after the Chicago World’s Fair? This paper analyzes five Potawatomi Removal stories told at the turn of the twentieth century. It argues that Midwestern settlers found their answer to “the Indian side” of the Removal question by telling the “Potawatomi” perspective of local history; featuring “authentic” representations of Native peoples in their stories and as witnesses to their efforts; perpetuating a myth that all the Potawatomi had been removed; condemning the actions of their “dishonorable and dishonest” forefathers; and publicly acknowledging that they were occupying stolen land. By claiming that the sons of the present were not the forefathers of the past, non-Indians were settling the story of Potawatomi Removal. In the process, they gave their community and their region a past that was simultaneously romantic and tragic, positioning themselves as its inheritors and interpreters.

Filed under: Uncategorized | Closed