Unreconstructed settler history vs settler colonial critique (of course, one sells, the other doesn’t): Honor Sachs, ‘The Unbearable Greatness of Pioneering: Storytelling in David McCullough’s The Pioneers’, Journal of the Early Republic, 41, 2, 2021, pp. 209-216 | settler colonial studies blog

Unreconstructed settler history vs settler colonial critique (of course, one sells, the other doesn’t): Honor Sachs, ‘The Unbearable Greatness of Pioneering: Storytelling in David McCullough’s The Pioneers’, Journal of the Early Republic, 41, 2, 2021, pp. 209-216

07Jun21

Abstract: In The Pioneers: The Heroic Story of the Settlers Who Brought the American Ideal West, author David McCullough tells a story of the white heroes who settled the Ohio Territory. McCullough describes a story of intrepid pioneers with noble intentions who endeavored to advance the American Dream. His work, however, ignores decades of historical scholarship that challenge such triumphant narratives and reveal the darker consequences of American exceptionalism. By excluding recent scholarship, McCullough’s work excuses the violence of settler colonialism and fails to capture the complex history of this region.

Filed under: Uncategorized | Closed