« The early Soviet stance against settler colonialism: Alexey Golubev, ‘No natural colonization: the early Soviet school of historical anti-colonialism’, Canadian Slavonic Papers, 2023
The virulent settler state: Theresa Rocha Beardall, ‘Social-Distancing the Settler-State: Indigenous Peoples in the Age of COVID-19’, in Glenn W. Muschert, Kristen M. Budd, David C. Lane, Jason A. Smith (eds), Social Problems in the Age of COVID-19, Vol 2, Cambridge University Press, 2023 »

Carbon settler colonialism: Faith Elizabeth Howard, An Analysis of the Suruí Forest Carbon Project in Context of Settler Colonialism, MA dissertation, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, 2023

30May23

Abstract: This thesis analyzes the Suruí Forest Carbon Project in the context of settler colonialism. By exploring the three core principles of settler colonialism as outlined by settler colonial scholar Patrick Wolfe: access to land, elimination of the native, and the understanding that settler colonialism is a structure and not an event, I will demonstrate how each one of the three principles helped contribute to creating the context within which the Suruí Forest Carbon Project was situated. By taking this approach, I will be able to demonstrate the limits and possibilities of the project for the Suruí indigenous peoples. This analysis will allow me to present the challenges and contradictions associated with implementing REDD+ carbon credit projects in settler states such as Brazil and how, due to settler colonialism’s structural limitations, these types of projects could be a possibility of providing some agency for indigenous peoples trying to find ways to assert their autonomy. The Suruí Forest Carbon Project was the first and still one of the only examples of an indigenous-led carbon emissions reduction project operating through the sale of carbon credits. During the first five years the project was operational, it drastically helped reduce deforestation levels within the Suruí’s territory, leading many to deem the project a success. However, in 2015 and 2016, following the discovery of gold and diamonds on the Suruí’s territory, the project’s sight was eventually overrun by garimpeiros (small-scale gold miners), and in 2018 the project was suspended, leading some to consider it a failure. Therefore, I will present some of the challenges that arise when neoliberal conservation efforts, such as carbon credit projects, struggle to address factors outside their initial control, in this case, settler colonialism. Also, by analyzing the different components going into the project’s creation, implementation, and suspension, I will present how carbon credit projects working directly with indigenous peoples can successfully halt deforestation for limited periods. But how settler colonialism makes these groups of people and their land vulnerable, which can help contribute to projects being undermined. Through my analysis, I will help demonstrate some factors that impact these types of projects’ longevity and some things that would need to be implemented in the future to succeed in the long term.


Filed under: Uncategorized   |  Closed