Is it Settler colonialism or internal colonialism? Why not both? Warren Bernauer ‘”Settler” and “internal” colonialism in “Canada”: Reconciling competing conceptual approaches to Canadian Colonialism in the North, Human Geography, 2024 | settler colonial studies blog

Is it Settler colonialism or internal colonialism? Why not both? Warren Bernauer ‘”Settler” and “internal” colonialism in “Canada”: Reconciling competing conceptual approaches to Canadian Colonialism in the North, Human Geography, 2024

28Nov24

Abstract: Geography scholarship about Indigenous politics in Canada frequently draws upon ideas from the field of settler colonial studies (SCS). Yet, criticisms of SCS and the application of its concepts to Canadian contexts are becoming increasingly common. Such criticisms include: an overly rigid distinction between settler colonialism and so-called ‘franchise’ colonialism, a tendency to rely on a small number of non-Indigenous scholars as foundational thinkers in the field and a lack of attention to the ways in which Canadian colonialism has varied across space-time. This article argues that re-engaging the concept of ‘internal colonialism’ – an older approach that focuses on identifying parallels between the imperialist domination of the third world and the colonial subjugation of peoples that are ‘internal’ to nation states – can help advance our understanding of Canadian colonialism.

Filed under: Uncategorized | Closed