Howard Williams, ‘Colonialism in Kant’s Political Philosophy’, Diametros 39 (2014).
This article examines the controversy that has arisen concerning the interpretation of Immanuel Kant’s account of European colonialism. One the one hand there are those interpreters such as Robert Bernasconi who see Kant’s account as all of a piece with his earlier views on race which demonstrate a certain narrow mindedness in relation to black and coloured people and, on the other hand, there are those such as Pauline Kleingeld and Allen Wood who argue that the earlier writings on race are not wholly typical of Kant’s approach and suggest that Kant’s later discussions of colonialism in Perpetual Peace and the Metaphysics of Morals provide a better indication of Kant’s progressive views on the treatment of non-European societies. The article draws attention to the very strong evidence of Kant’s dislike for the pattern of European expansion to other parts of the globe and indicates that within Kant’s writings there are the seeds of a wholly unconventional critical understanding of western colonialism that have yet to be developed fully. The article suggests that this critical understanding surpasses the unsystematic objections made to colonialism in post – modernist thought and also the critique proffered by the determinist Marxist account
Filed under: Uncategorized | Closed
This essay argues that recent scholarship in world history has accrued data calling for changed analytical models in postcolonial, Marxist and cultural studies. Documenting transcontinental interactions in ancient and medieval periods, scholars have rewritten longstanding narratives of finance, trade, labour, science and religion, with crucial implications for the arts as they operate within a (post)colonial and world-systems terrain. The data reveal a dialectic of historical materialism encompassing multi-directional interactions over a very longue durée: dynamic and uneven, yet systemic and accretive – and formative for ‘modern’ history. The essay offers one theoretical framework – of ‘inter-imperiality’ – for analysing this data so as to highlight dialectics in the material, the political and the cultural fields, which pre-date and prepare western European states’ entry into an Afro-Eurasian world-system. An inter-imperial model on the one hand expands the relevance of postcolonial models, and on the other hand it transforms them – encompassing, as it does, a political–economic field of several empires operating simultaneously in every period since ancient eras, and in relation to capitalist formations. The essay argues finally that such a model clarifies how elite and non-elite actors occupy an ‘inter-imperial positionality’ from which they variously shape the emergence of economic, material and cultural infrastructures.
Filed under: Uncategorized | Closed
It’s called mazacoin, and the man who developed it, Payu Harris, wants to make it the official currency of the Lakota Nation, a semi-autonomous North American Indian reservation in South Dakota. Officially launched in February, its market cap of $3.3 million places it 20th among alternative currencies (there are more than 200 “alt-coins,” although most have marginal significance).
Official adoption by the Lakota Nation would be a big development in the world of virtual currencies, because until now, the storyline for bitcoin alternatives has been about a small group of technophiles playing with a shiny new toy. But to Mr. Harris, the idea of a national currency represents something for which he’s been striving for a long time: independence.
“I’ve been studying tribal sovereignty since I was 16,” said Mr. Harris, the Lakota who developed and is promoting mazacoin. “To be a truly independent state you have to have your own issued currency.”
Paul Vigna for Wall Street Journal.
Filed under: Uncategorized | Closed
Stephanie Lawson, ‘The Politics of Indigenous Identity: An Introductory Commentary’
Braden Hill, ‘Searching for Certainty in Purity: Indigenous Fundamentalism’
Dominic O’Sullivan, ‘Indigeneity, Ethnicity, and the State: Australia, Fiji, and New Zealand’
Katherine Smits, ‘The Neoliberal State and the Uses of Indigenous Culture’
Margaret Forster, ‘Indigeneity and Trends in Recognizing Māori Environmental Interests in Aotearoa New Zealand’
Jeanne Simon & Claudio J. González-Parra, ‘International Norms and National Indigenous Politics: Mapuche Demands for Territory in Chile’
Nameirakpam Bijen Meetei, ‘Ethnicity, Colonial Legacies, and Postindependence Issues of Identity Politics in North-East India’
Lailufar Yasmin, ‘The Tyranny of the Majority in Bangladesh: The Case of the Chittagong Hill Tracts’
Adrian Guelke, ‘Northern Ireland’s Flags Crisis and the Enduring Legacy of the Settler-Native Divide’
Filed under: Uncategorized | Closed
One of the most powerful narratives deployed by colonists in the nineteenth century was that the colonized natives were inherently too weak to survive contact with those who were colonizing them—the Dying Native story. I argue that to understand the history of this story, we should differentiate between three senses in which it could be taken as true or false: physical destruction, genetic adulteration and loss of distinct culture. The physical destruction version of the “Dying Native” was contested by some settler-colonial governments as they developed the capacity to manage and measure the numbers of those whom they classified as “Indian” or “Māori” or “Aboriginal”. However, the “Dying Native” story persisted as a narrative of these peoples’ loss of genetic and/or cultural distinction. One strategy of Indigenous intellectuals has been to assert that they have survived as “populations” by adapting as “peoples”. In this paper, I show how an authoritative demography of colonized Indigenous populations in North America and New Zealand afforded discursive opportunities to some Indigenous intellectuals.
Filed under: Uncategorized | Closed
This article discusses the recent proliferation of North American Indigenous conservation efforts in the form of tribal national parks. To varying degrees, tribal parks offer alternative perspectives to conservation studies by accounting for land-based epistemologies and practices. They also raise pressing questions: To what extent are tribal natural resource managers in North America assuming the role of state authorities in their ability to restrict citizen access to tribal lands? How do tribal conservation areas differ from state-sanctioned enclosures throughout the globe that often disenfranchise customary use by local peoples? In dialog with political–ecological studies of conservation enclosures, I argue that Indigenous nations are transforming the concept of enclosure in their systemic reclamations of Indigenous sovereignty and territory through environmental stewardship. The analysis is based on a survey of tribal parks in the United States and Canada.
Filed under: Uncategorized | Closed
The aim of this article is to place forced evictions in their legal-historical context by analysing the rural and urban land tenure measures used during apartheid to limit the nature and duration of black people’s tenure. The hypothesis of this article is that the homelessness and extensive housing crisis in present-day South Africa have their origins in the apartheid era, when government’s rural and urban land tenure measures, together with private owners’ common-law remedies, led to large-scale forced evictions. A renewed appreciation of the legal-historical context of forced evictions should enable the courts to understand the social and historical context of section 26 of the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996 and the Prevention of Illegal Evictions from and Unlawful Occupation of Land Act 18 of 1998. This limited historical study places forced removals and the demolition of homes in the context of apartheid land law. The description and analysis of legislation and case law are limited to the period between 1913 when the Black Land Act was enacted and 1994 which marked the official end of apartheid.
Filed under: Uncategorized | Closed
A shocking exposé of how modern-day corporations and governments are raiding the Third World
To the governments and corporations buying up vast tracts of the Third World, it is ‘land leasing’; to its critics, it is nothing better than ‘land grabbing’ – the engine powering a new era of colonialism.
In this arresting account of how millions of hectares of fertile soil are stolen to feed wealthy westerners thousands of miles away, journalist Stefano Liberti takes readers on a tour of contemporary exploitation. It is a journey encompassing a Dutch-owned model farm in Ethiopia; a conference in Riyadh, where representatives of Third World governments compete to attract Saudi investors; meetings in Rome where the fate of nations is decided; and the headquarters of the Movement of Landless Workers in São Paulo.
Since the food crisis of 2007–8, when the cost of staples such as rice and corn went through the roof, the race to acquire land in the southern hemisphere has become more intense than ever. Land Grabbing is the shocking story of how one half of the world is starved to feed the other.
Filed under: Uncategorized | Closed
This chapter focuses on the reasons why history-writing remains so controversial in the settler national historiographies. The author argues that embracing a historical methodology or rejecting it altogether is part of a dilemma that is specific to the settler colonial “situation”. In doing so, he claims that the structuring relational distinction between “indigenous” peoples and settlers is ultimately a distinction between historical and ontological relations to land. The writing of history, however “history” may be defined, was bound to be crucial. If indigenous ontological relations to the land are often premised on emergence myths/creation stories, one crucial device for the denial of indigenous title and/or special rights is the so-called “tide of history” argument. Here is Waldron’s logic: Indigenous claims are based either on the principle of first occupancy or on the principle of prior occupancy; the two principles are not the same.
Filed under: Uncategorized | Closed