‘Reconciliation’ as a (juridical practice of) dispossession: Nicole Van Lier, ‘Reconciliation 2.0: Resolving Contradictions in the Production of Settler Colonial and Capitalist Space in Canada’, Antipode, 2021

12Jan21

Abstract: This paper reviews a pair of Canadian legal decisions on the duty to consult to explore the court’s role in reconciling tensions between settler colonial and capitalist space. Following a period of political and economic instability that made energy development vulnerable to Indigenous legal challenge, the court legalised the delegation of Indigenous consultations to corporate and regulatory actors, defined consultation in practical terms, and intensified the remedy for inadequate consultation. The court not only substituted nation‐to‐nation negotiations with corporate engagements, but submitted energy corporations to the work of legitimising and effectuating Canadian sovereignty. The decisions call for an expanded view of “reconciliation” as a judicial practice of Indigenous dispossession, accomplished not only by reconciling Indigenous authority with Canadian sovereignty, but by reconciling capitalist energy development with the legalities of Canada’s modern settler colonial order. The decisions bring into greater focus the state’s increasing reliance on corporations to reproduce Canadian sovereignty.

Filed under: Uncategorized | Closed

Settler colonialism is a global and transnational phenomenon, and as much a thing of the past as a thing of the present. Settlers 'come to stay': they are founders of political orders who carry with them a distinct sovereign capacity.
If you're a scholar, and you find some of your work featured on the blog, then chances are that we want it for our journal.
what’s new
- Colonial continuities: Jane Lydon, ‘Racial Punishment from Slavery to Settler Colonialism: John Picton Beete in Demerara and Swan River’, Slavery and Abolition, 2022
- The irony of settler colonialism: Alex Trimble Young, ‘”The Vigorous New Vernacular”: Settler Colonialism and the Politics of Irony in Roughing It‘, The Mark Twain Annual, 20, 2022, pp. 158-173
- The present settler colonial imperative: Judy Rohrer, ‘Imperial Dis-ease: Trump’s Border Wall, Obama’s Sea Wall, and Settler Colonial Failure’, American Quarterly, 74, 3, 2022, pp. 737-763
- Poetical settler colonialism: Tayseer Abu Odeh, ‘The Politics of Yehuda Amichai’s Aesthetic Camouflage: Jerusalem and the Settler-Colonial Gaze’, Journal of Holy Land and Palestine Studies, 2022
- The spatiotemporality of settler colonialism and its alternative: C. M. Peacock, Indigenous feminist philosophy in Idle No More: theorizing the space-time of Canada’s settler colonial politics and alternative decolonial imaginaries, PhD dissertation, University of Calgary, 2022
- The settler colonial carceral archipelago: Krystal Lockwood, Bhiamie Williamson, ‘The shackles of masculinity: Indigenous men, settler colonialism, and the carceral archipelago’, in Tess Bartlett, Rosemary Ricciardelli (eds), Prison Masculinities: International Perspectives and Interpretations, Routledge, 2022
- Settler violence and screen violence: Henrik Gustafsson, ‘Screen Violence from Settler Colonialism to Cognitive Capitalism: Westworld and the Player Piano’, Afterimage, 49, 3, 2022, pp. 23-45
- Settler schooling: Sean Carleton, Lessons in Legitimacy: Colonialism, Capitalism, and the Rise of State Schooling in British Columbia, UBC Press, 2022
- Indigenous sovereignty is sustainable (settler colonialism is not): Melissa Catherine Helen Gorrie, Transformation beyond the settler legal paradigm: grounding ecologically-focused legal theories in relational accountability to address settler colonialism and support Indigenous sovereignty, MA dissertation, University of Calgary, 2022
- Settler colonial ableism: Alec Moore, Tracing the Colonial Dimensions of ‘Special Education’: History, Disability, and Settler Colonialism, MA dissertation, Brock University, 2022
- Can it even be a question? Yitzhak Benbaji, ‘Is Egalitarian Zionism Wrongful Colonialism?’ Philosophia, 2022
- Comparing settler colonial environments: Tom Lynch, Outback and Out West: The Settler-Colonial Environmental Imaginary, University of Nebraska Press, 2022
- Comparing settler colonialisms: Jacob Tropp, ‘U.S. Indian Affairs, British Imperial Africa, and Transcolonial Dialogues over Conservation and “Native Development” in the 1930s’, Journal of World History, 33, 3, 2022, p. 459-489
- Agrarian reform against settler colonialism in Latin America: Joanna Crow, ‘Indigeneity, Land and Property’, in Joanna Crow, Itinerant Ideas, Palgrave, 2022, pp. 69-100
- The reconciliation of one Asian settler society: Scott E. Simon, Jolan Hsieh, Peter Kang (eds), Indigenous Reconciliation in Contemporary Taiwan: From Stigma to Hope, Routledge, 2023
contribute

email the editor

‘Reconciliation’ as a (juridical practice of) dispossession: Nicole Van Lier, ‘Reconciliation 2.0: Resolving Contradictions in the Production of Settler Colonial and Capitalist Space in Canada’, Antipode, 2021

Share this:

Like this:

Related

what’s new

contribute