Abstract: A long tumultuous history between Indigenous Peoples and police continues to negatively impact Indigenous Peoples in the criminal justice system to this day. In collaboration with the Portland Committee on Community-Engaged Policing, the current research explored how Indigenous-police interactions are represented in news, social media and scholarly literature. A content analysis was conducted on news articles (n = 50), Tweets (n = 268) and scholarly articles (n = 58). The main findings revealed news often favored police in their depictions, while social media favored Indigenous Peoples. However, both sources lacked adequate representation of Indigenous perspectives and voices. On the other hand, the scholarly literature was more representative of both police and Indigenous perspectives while focusing on overall issues within the criminal justice system as opposed to a singular party being at fault. These findings highlight the differences in depictions across media outlets and the importance of well-rounded media consumption on Indigenous-police interactions to avoid skewed perceptions.