Settler conservation is … settler colonial: David Craig Baumeister, Lauren Eichler, ‘Settler Colonialism and the US Conservation Movement: Contesting Histories, Indigenizing Futures’, Ethics, Policy & the Environment, 2021 | settler colonial studies blog

Settler conservation is … settler colonial: David Craig Baumeister, Lauren Eichler, ‘Settler Colonialism and the US Conservation Movement: Contesting Histories, Indigenizing Futures’, Ethics, Policy & the Environment, 2021

08Dec21

Abstract: Despite recent strides in the direction of achieving a more equitable and genuine place for Indigenous voices in the conservation conversation, the conservation movement must more deliberately and thoroughly grapple with the legacy of its deeply settler colonial history if it is to, in actuality and not merely in rhetoric, achieve the aim of being more equitable. In this article, we show how the conservation movement, historically and still largely today, traffics in certain ethical and political values that are, in principle or in effect, anti-Indigenous. Through this examination, we hope to reveal how present-day conservation efforts, even if ‘well-meaning’ or nominally deferential regarding Indigenous peoples and perspectives, in fact reinforce settler colonial structures. In particular, we critique the notion of the uninhabited wilderness as a conservation ideal and the disavowal of originary violence (along with a parallel positing of settler nativism) in the articulation of conservation historicity and the founding of conservation movements. We conclude by offering some steps conservationists can take to alter their practices, methods, and values in ways that recognize, respect, and reciprocate with Indigenous peoples.

Filed under: Uncategorized | Closed

%d bloggers like this: